Fitbit vs. Apple Watch

Pedometers that rely the variety of steps you’re taking every day have been round because the Nineteen Sixties. However health tech obtained an actual shot within the arm in 2008 when Fitbit, the primary wearable health monitoring system, hit the market.

(Getty Pictures)

Since then, Fitbit and a number of other different corporations have developed an ever-evolving array of wearable gadgets which are supposed to quietly come alongside for the trip of your life whereas conserving tabs on each bodily factor you do. This fixed monitoring of motion, sleep patterns and fundamental well being information has created an entire new approach to have a look at health and easy methods to be sure you’re doing the fitting issues on the proper occasions to assist optimum well being and wellness.

How Health Trackers Work

These wearable expertise gadgets use an accelerometer to sense and measure motion. The info is saved and, relying on the kind of system, is perhaps instantly viewable on the wrist show or should be linked to a pc to investigate the info later.

“These gadgets provide you with suggestions and information about your actions all through the day.” The goal is that will help you perceive your patterns and the place you may be capable of make significant changes to enhance general well being.

Right this moment, choices for a way to do that abound, however two of essentially the most recognizable and common manufacturers of wearable health trackers – each worn on the wrist – are the well-established Fitbit and the newer Apple Watch.


Borchers is a devotee of each the Fitbit and the Apple Watch, and says that the Fitbit is extra oriented in the direction of getting individuals transferring. “The principle purpose is steps. You may hear individuals speaking about ‘getting their steps in,’ and that is as a result of the Fitbit is tremendous massive on hitting a ten,000 steps per day step rely,” she explains.

That 10,000-step purpose harkens again to one of many very first pedometers designed within the mid-Nineteen Sixties. A Japanese researcher named Dr. Yoshiro Hatano at Kyushu College of Well being and Welfare was investigating methods to sluggish rising weight problems charges and decided that strolling 10,000 steps every day was a easy metric to assist individuals discover the fitting stability between energy ingested and energy burned.

He invented a pedometer referred to as the Manpo-kei, which interprets as “10,000 steps meter,” that will assist individuals meet that purpose. The idea of attempting to stroll at the least 10,000 steps per day has been a prevailing exercise-for-weight-management concept ever since.

Fitbit merchandise include 10,000 steps as a default purpose, however you possibly can regulate it to your wants. “For some individuals, 7,000 steps is perhaps an applicable purpose,” Borchers says. However for somebody who’s a marathoner, “they are going to be far exceeding the ten,000-step rely” and may wish to set it larger.

Over the previous a number of years, Fitbit has grow to be a market chief in steps and health monitoring, and the corporate presents a number of trackers and smartwatches. Whereas Fitbit merchandise emphasize strolling, in addition they observe different varieties of exercise, comparable to operating, biking, yoga and energy coaching.

Fitbit wearables observe a variety of health measures together with:

  • Train minutes, steps or miles walked and flooring climbed.
  • Energy burned, which is calculated utilizing your basal metabolic price (the speed at which you burn energy at relaxation) and your exercise information. For gadgets that observe coronary heart price, that info helps calculate a extra exact calories-burned estimate. 
  • Progress towards weight-loss objectives, which the consumer can replace by way of the app to earn award “badges.”
  • Well being metrics, together with coronary heart price, respiration price, pores and skin temperature and oxygen saturation which are accessible with a premium membership.
  • Sleep.

Borchers says that the Fitbit presents a number of element about sleep period and high quality should you go for the premium membership, which requires an extra month-to-month subscription price of $9.99 per 30 days or $79.99 for the yr. That function offers you entry to all types of knowledge about your sleep, comparable to how lengthy you sleep, how lengthy you spend in deep sleep, how stressed you might be at evening, physique temperature adjustments and your coronary heart and respiration price. When you do not sleep nicely, this info may very well be very useful for bettering your means to get the remainder you want.

The premium membership additionally offers entry to greater than 200 extra exercises from Fitbit and different common manufacturers together with different add-on options that make for a extra sturdy and well-rounded health device.

At present, the corporate presents three smartwatches that supply a variety of health choices, in addition to lots of the options you’d discover on a smartphone, comparable to the flexibility to take incoming calls and ship textual content messages, hearken to music and use apps.

The smartwatch fashions presently accessible embrace:

  • Fitbit Sense: $299.95.
  • Fitbit Versa 3: $229.95.
  • Fitbit Versa 2: $179.95.

In distinction, the trackers are easier gadgets that do not have fairly as many bells and whistles because the smartwatches however can nonetheless supply a variety of well being information and a few extras relying on the mannequin.
The vary of trackers consists of:

  • Fitbit Cost 5: $179.95.
  • Fitbit Luxe: $149.95.
  • Fitbit Encourage 2: $99.95.
  • Fitbit Ace 3: $79.95. (for youths ages 6 and up)

Fitbit merchandise are swim proof and designed to sync with each Apple and Android gadgets. Some gadgets have Wi-Fi and GPS capabilities.

Apple Watch

The Apple Watch, which is designed to sync with different Apple merchandise, is organized slightly in another way and helps you set and obtain every day health objectives utilizing a set of three round graphs, referred to as rings, displayed digitally on the face of the watch. The thought is to “shut your rings” to satisfy all three objectives every day.

  • Transfer. The primary ring exhibits the variety of energetic energy you burn every day. “The watch units a advice for you primarily based in your age, your weight and your exercise stage,” Borchers says. You possibly can regulate that focus on if you would like. For instance, should you’re extra sedentary and “by no means hitting my purpose, the watch may advocate that I decrease that purpose,” she explains. When you’re attempting to burn extra energy to drop a few pounds, you possibly can set the purpose larger in order that the watch will remind you to maintain transferring all through the day.
  • Train. The second ring tracks how a lot train you have interaction in all through the day, whether or not that is steps taken, loops cycled or laps swum. It routinely units an train purpose of half-hour every day, which will also be adjusted in line with your wants. The watch will routinely seize an train in case your coronary heart price exceeds a goal stage, which can also be adjustable. If you are going to do a light-weight yoga exercise, for instance, you can begin the train tracker manually to seize that as train.
  • Stand ring. The third ring helps remind you to maintain transferring all through the day. “That function offers me a cue 10 minutes earlier than each hour that I must stand up and transfer round,” Borchers says. The thought is to be sure you’re standing up for at the least one minute as soon as an hour so you do not get too sedentary.

The Apple Watch tracks coronary heart price and can notify you if it detects an irregular coronary heart rhythm or a price that is abnormally excessive or low. The very best-end mannequin additionally presents a blood oxygen and electrocardiogram, or ECG, app to provide you extra heart-health information. These add-ons do not require any extra tools – sensors within the watch are capable of detect your coronary heart rhythm by way of contact with the wrist to supply this info.

All fashions have a security function referred to as Emergency SOS that may assist emergency responders find you. Some fashions additionally supply worldwide emergency calls, a compass, fall detection and an always-on altimeter as choices.

The Apple Watch tracks sleep should you put on it in a single day, however the information is restricted and focuses on what number of hours you’ve got been asleep. It would not present as many insights about sleep high quality because the Fitbit does.

The Apple Watch comes with Wi-Fi connectivity, and you’ll add GPS and mobile connections as added options. All Apple Watch merchandise are listed as waterproof to a depth of fifty meters and “swim proof,” making them a very good possibility for individuals who get their train in moist environments.

There are three collection of Apple Watches accessible from the corporate presently:

  • Apple Watch Collection 7. That is essentially the most just lately launched possibility. It is available in two sizes – 45 millimeters and 41 mm – and a number of other colours and case supplies. You possibly can swap out the band for nearly any fashion or shade you need. All these variations make for various costs, however the base 41 mm mannequin begins at $399. Including mobile service in addition to totally different case and band choices can elevate the value considerably.
  • Apple Watch SE. This can be a streamlined model of the older collection 6 fashion that begins at $279.
  • Apple Watch Collection 3. That is an older iteration of the Apple Watch that is presently accessible, beginning at $199.

Fitbit vs. Apple Watch: Which Is Higher?

Borchers says that determining which wearable is the higher possibility is determined by what your objectives are and what kind of info is most essential to you. For instance, if you would like a number of details about your sleep high quality however aren’t as bothered about extreme information on exercises, then the Fitbit is the higher possibility. And, as a result of Fitbit merchandise sync with each Apple and Android gadgets, should you use a PC or carry round a Google cellphone, the Fitbit is probably going going to be the higher possibility for you.

Nonetheless, should you do need the extra granular exercise information and you’ve got an iPhone, then the Apple Watch will probably be the higher match.

When you have the means, contemplate getting each, Borchers says. “I began out with a Fitbit, and it was an awesome introduction to getting information and having my exercise tracked and logged. Then, I switched to the Apple Watch. I’ve an iPhone, and it is extra appropriate with that, and it is (the Apple Watch) slightly larger tech and data-driven. For me, that was the fitting swap to make,” she says.

Nonetheless, Fitbit merchandise are usually rather less costly, and so they do supply extra information about sleep. So actually, all of it comes all the way down to what makes essentially the most sense to your well being wants, pursuits and funds. “Each have their place in the marketplace for a motive. It is simply selecting which is best for you,” Borchers says.

It doesn’t matter what your objectives, Borchers provides that these wearable gadgets could be actually helpful and supportive of creating higher well being and health habits. “It is simply an additional motivator to stand up and get transferring to assist together with your general bodily exercise stage.”

Person Critiques

Three wearables customers share their experiences with Fitbit and Apple Watch merchandise beneath and spotlight which system works finest for them and why.

Tried Them All and Caught with Apple

Meredith Hunt, a runner primarily based in Beverly, Massachusetts, who describes herself as an “avid client of wearables” has used each Fitbit and Apple Watch merchandise and says, that whereas it’s been a number of years since she used Fitbit, her impression of it was that “the expertise was actually fundamental. The interface wasn’t thrilling or advances and looks-wise it appeared low-cost.” She additionally had a number of points with the band breaking, a typical drawback that many Fitbit customers have additionally reported.

She disliked the system a lot that she purchased a Garmin watch to assist along with her operating coaching. “I used to be a lot happier with the standard distinction, however because the expertise advances, I wished extra of a smartwatch that had extra featured past simply monitoring runs and steps.”

Enter the Apple Watch, which she says is “the most effective smartwatch I’ve used.” However she hastened so as to add that she additionally had an iPhone and different apple merchandise, “so exterior of that ecosystem, I’m undecided how nice it will be.”

Hunt says that the options she likes essentially the most on her Apple Watch are:

  • Exercise monitoring – it’s simple.
  • Step counts.
  • Notifications from her cellphone that preserve her “linked with out having to maintain my cellphone out on a regular basis.”
  • Alerts for respiration, a mindfulness operate the place the watch makes a sound and urges the wearer to take a second to breathe.
  • Alerts for standing, an analogous operate the place the watch alerts the wearer that it’s time to face up should you’ve been sedentary for too lengthy.
  • App integration, which permits the consumer so as to add applications comparable to Spotify instantly. “That compatibility crushes different wearables in my expertise,” Hunt says.

She says the Health+ membership additionally has a number of extra exercise choices that she’s solely simply begun exploring. On the draw back, she notes that the Apple Watch must be charged every day because the battery life is restricted – a typical grievance amongst Apple Watch customers.

FitBit Modified Her Life

Ellen Morfei of Media, Pennsylvania, says that her Fitbit modified her life. “I hate delusion – in me and others. Have all the issues you need, however come clean with them,” she says.

And buying a Fitbit helped her do exactly that for her personal well-being. “I had not been proudly owning as much as my meals consumption – high quality or amount – or my (lack of) motion. Fitbit was an enormous a part of ending my delusions.”

She says lastly getting actual about meals consumption, motion ranges and sleep high quality remodeled her complete outlook on life. “I’m down 31 kilos, however that’s not an awesome measure of how I’ve shifted my well being and well-being. I’m 54 years outdated. I must cease believing my BS and arrange well being patterns that will assist a wholesome life for a few years to return. Fitbit was one of some instruments that made an enormous distinction for me. I’m not deluding myself anymore.”

Having the ability to see in black and white what she was doing made it exhausting to rationalize making much less wholesome decisions. She concludes by saying, “I consider in information,” and her Fitbit gave her the figures she wanted to make wholesome adjustments in how she lives her life everyday.

Apple Watch Guidelines the Day

William Driscoll, a biomedical engineer and runner primarily based in Salem, Massachusetts, says that he’s been utilizing an Apple Look ahead to monitoring his operating since about 2018 when the Garmin watch he had been utilizing broke. “I dabbled in Fitbit as a pedometer/step counter however didn’t discover it helpful for my wants.” Driscoll wished extra superior run monitoring choices that will combine with different apps, comparable to Strava and iSmoothrun, and he discovered that Apple Watch labored nicely with these third-party applications.

“Apple Watch supported the native Strava app on the watch in addition to different run apps,” he says, and it was simple for him to switch all the info from his Garmin (which had been uploaded to a different website referred to as Runkeeper) to Strava, “so I used to be glad to keep up all of that historic information and never depend on the watch platform for my information log and analytics.”

Apple Watch additionally match nicely into the remainder of his life, he says. “I did not wish to have a separate watch/system/wearable for operating, a separate look ahead to work, a separate system for exercise monitoring and to depend on my cellphone on my run.” Integrating all of these wants and makes use of right into a single system made issues easier.

Driscoll may join along with his household by way of the Apple platform, and so they can problem one another. “It’s good to see a notification that my niece in Scotland simply completed a exercise,” for instance.

He provides that the Apple Watch’s GPS accuracy is sweet, and that it connects immediately makes it higher than the Garmin, which all the time took a very long time to attach. And the guts price information the watch collects is “ok.” He says he’s “examined many medical grade wearables for distant affected person monitoring and these present client tech gadgets are all positive for our day-to-day leisure wants.”

For his cash, “I believe that the Apple Watch serves my wants. If I will spend $400+ each three to 4 years on a watch/app platform for my every day use, it’s nicely definitely worth the cash.”

Leave a Comment